Skip to content

Break The Spell toolkit half price until 30 NovemberNine tools, ten days of access

Free checklist from Belfast Books

Questions to Ask Your Publisher

Before you sign anything, 23 questions written by a bookseller with a background in access to justice.

A publisher who won't answer these questions plainly is telling you something. A publisher who answers them confidently, with evidence, is worth listening to. The difference between the two is worth knowing before you sign anything. Print this. Take it to every meeting. Use it on every call. If they're legitimate, they'll respect you for it. If they're not, they'll show you.

Section 1

Who they are

Before you discuss your book, find out who you're dealing with. Most vanity presses present themselves as traditional publishers. These questions establish the truth quickly.

  1. 1.How do you make your money, from selling books or from charging authors?

    Why ask this. The most important question on this list. A legitimate publisher makes money when your book sells. A vanity press makes money the moment you sign. If they hesitate, deflect, or give you a non-answer, leave.

    Red flagAny suggestion that author fees are standard practice, a contribution to costs, or an investment in your future.

  2. 2.Are you a member of the Publishers Association or the Alliance of Independent Publishers?

    Why ask this. Legitimate UK publishers are typically members of trade organisations with codes of conduct. Membership isn't a guarantee of legitimacy but absence is a yellow flag worth noting.

  3. 3.How long have you been in business and under what name?

    Why ask this. Vanity presses regularly rebrand after accumulating negative reviews. Search the company's previous names. Check the Companies House register. Look for the directors' names across multiple companies.

    Red flagA company less than two years old with directors who have run multiple publishing companies under different names.

  4. 4.Can I speak to three authors you've published in the last two years?

    Why ask this. This is the question they don't want you to ask. A legitimate publisher with satisfied authors will provide references without hesitation. Ask specifically for authors whose books are similar to yours and who published recently. Written testimonials can be fabricated. A phone call can't.

    Red flagRefusal, delay, or offering written testimonials rather than direct contact details.

  5. 5.What were the sales figures for your last five titles?

    Why ask this. Ask for actual sales numbers, not percentages or vague claims about reach. A publisher who can't or won't give you sales figures for recent titles either doesn't track them or doesn't want you to know them.

    Red flagClaims of thousands of copies sold with no verifiable data.

Section 2

The contract

Never sign a publishing contract without having it reviewed by a qualified lawyer or the Society of Authors. The questions below are the minimum you should ask before that review takes place.

  1. 6.What rights are you asking me to sign over and for how long?

    Why ask this. A traditional publisher typically acquires specific rights for the duration of copyright or for a set period. A vanity press may ask for rights they've no intention or ability to exploit. Know exactly what you're signing away.

    Red flagDemands for world rights, all-format rights, and all-language rights with no reversion clause and no minimum sales threshold.

  2. 7.What's the reversion of rights clause? Under what circumstances do my rights return to me?

    Why ask this. A reversion clause defines when and how you can get your book back. If the publisher fails to keep the book in print, fails to sell above a minimum threshold, or goes out of business, the rights should revert to you automatically. If there's no reversion clause, or if the threshold is impossibly low, you may never get your book back.

    Red flagNo reversion clause. A reversion threshold set at "not less than one copy sold in any 12-month period", designed to prevent reversion indefinitely.

  3. 8.What's the royalty rate and how is it calculated, on gross or net receipts?

    Why ask this. A royalty on gross receipts means you earn a percentage of the cover price. A royalty on net receipts means you earn a percentage of what the publisher actually receives after the retailer takes their cut. The difference is significant.

    Red flagRoyalty rates that sound impressive but are calculated on net receipts after deductions for distribution, returns, and marketing costs.

  4. 9.Is there a non-compete clause and what does it cover?

    Why ask this. A non-compete clause prevents you from publishing similar work with another publisher for a set period. The definition of "similar" is everything. A badly drafted non-compete clause could prevent you from publishing your next book while your current publisher sits on the rights to your first one.

    Red flagNon-compete clauses with broad definitions of similarity, long time periods, or no geographic limitation.

  5. 10.Is there an option clause on my next book and what are its terms?

    Why ask this. An option clause gives the publisher first right of refusal on your next book. How long do they have to respond? At what royalty rate? What counts as a rejection? A poorly negotiated option clause can lock you into a relationship you want to leave.

    Red flagOption clauses with no time limit on the publisher's decision, or that allow the publisher to match any offer rather than simply refuse.

  6. 11.What happens to my book and my rights if the company goes out of business?

    Why ask this. Publishing companies fail. If yours does, you want your rights back automatically. Ask specifically what provision is made in the contract for insolvency. If there's none, your book and your rights could end up in the hands of an administrator or a creditor.

    Red flagNo provision for insolvency. Rights assigned to the company outright rather than licensed.

Section 3

The money

If a publisher is asking you to pay anything, for editing, design, printing, distribution, or marketing, you're dealing with a vanity press regardless of what they call themselves. The questions below apply to both traditional and vanity publishers.

  1. 12.Am I being asked to pay anything at any stage of this process?

    Why ask this. A traditional publisher pays all costs. A vanity press charges you. Some disguise the charges as optional upgrades, marketing packages, or premium services. Ask directly whether any payment from you is expected at any point.

    Red flagAny payment request whatsoever from a publisher who approached you, or from a publisher who guaranteed to publish your book.

  2. 13.How and when are royalties paid? What's the accounting period?

    Why ask this. Royalties should be paid on a regular schedule, typically twice yearly, with a clear accounting statement showing copies sold, returns, and net earnings. Ask for a sample royalty statement from a current author.

    Red flagRoyalty statements paid annually or less frequently. No clear breakdown of sales by territory, format, or channel.

  3. 14.What's your returns policy and how do returns affect my royalties?

    Why ask this. Bookshops can return unsold stock to publishers. Returns are deducted from your royalty calculations. Ask what percentage of sales are typically returned and how this affects your statements.

    Red flagUnreasonably high returns reserves held indefinitely.

  4. 15.What's the print run and who owns the stock?

    Why ask this. For print-on-demand books there's no print run. For offset-printed books, ask how many copies are being printed, where they're stored, and what happens to unsold stock. You don't want to end up responsible for a warehouse of books you can't sell.

    Red flagLarge print runs for first-time authors with no proven sales track record. Storage costs charged to the author.

Section 4

Editorial and production

  1. 16.Who will edit my book and what are their credentials?

    Why ask this. Ask for the editor's name, their publishing background, and examples of books they've edited. A legitimate publisher employs or commissions experienced editors. A vanity press may run your manuscript through a basic proofread and call it edited.

    Red flagEditors with no verifiable publishing background. Editing described vaguely as a "review" or "polish."

  2. 17.Can I see examples of covers you've designed for similar books?

    Why ask this. Ask to see recent cover designs. Look at them on Amazon. Would you pick them up? Do they look professional? Do they fit the genre? A bad cover kills a good book.

    Red flagCovers that look self-designed. Stock photography used without customisation.

  3. 18.Will I have approval over the final cover and interior design?

    Why ask this. You should have approval rights over your cover and the right to reject designs that don't represent your book correctly.

    Red flagContracts that give the publisher sole creative control while charging the author for the design.

  4. 19.What's the production timeline from signing to publication?

    Why ask this. A realistic production timeline for a properly edited and designed book is six to twelve months. Promises of faster publication should be questioned, faster usually means less thorough.

    Red flagPromises of publication within weeks. No clear timeline in the contract.

Section 5

Distribution and marketing

  1. 20.Which distributors do you use and will my book be available to UK bookshops and libraries?

    Why ask this. For a book to be stocked in UK bookshops and libraries it needs to be distributed through Gardners or Bertrams or through IngramSpark. A book available only on Amazon isn't properly distributed.

    Red flagDistribution described as "available on Amazon and major online retailers". This isn't the same as being available to bookshops and libraries.

  2. 21.What specific marketing activity will you undertake for my book?

    Why ask this. Ask for a specific written marketing plan. What publications will they approach for reviews? What events will they submit the book for? Who specifically will be doing this work?

    Red flagVague promises of marketing support with no specifics. Marketing described as the author's responsibility.

  3. 22.Will my book be submitted for relevant awards and prizes?

    Why ask this. Prize submissions require planning, timing, and relationships with prize administrators. Ask which prizes your book will be submitted for and what the track record is.

  4. 23.What's your strategy for selling translation rights and who handles this?

    Why ask this. Translation rights can generate significant income. Ask whether the publisher has a rights department and attends the Frankfurt and London Book Fairs.

    Red flagNo rights department. No attendance at major book fairs. No examples of translation deals.

Section 6

The red flag checklist

Any one of the following should give you serious pause. More than two and you should walk away.

  1. 1.They approached you unsolicited.

    Legitimate publishers receive submissions. They don't cold-call authors. An unsolicited approach is almost always a vanity press fishing for paying clients.

  2. 2.They guaranteed to publish your book.

    No legitimate publisher guarantees publication before reading your manuscript. Guaranteed publication means their business model doesn't depend on your book being good.

  3. 3.They asked you to pay anything.

    Full stop. A traditional publisher pays you. They don't ask you to pay them.

  4. 4.They couldn't or wouldn't provide author references.

    Three current authors. Direct contact. If they won't provide this, ask yourself why.

  5. 5.The contract has no reversion of rights clause.

    Without a reversion clause your book is theirs indefinitely regardless of how poorly it performs.

  6. 6.They couldn't give you actual sales figures for recent titles.

    A publisher who doesn't track sales or won't share them isn't running a serious publishing business.

  7. 7.They described your manuscript as ready to publish without reading it.

    No legitimate editor approves a manuscript without reading it. If they told you it was publication-ready before seeing it, they're not editing. They're selling.

  8. 8.The contract has a non-compete clause with a broad or undefined scope.

    This could prevent you from publishing anything for years.

  9. 9.They pressure you to sign quickly.

    Good publishers don't need to rush you. Pressure to sign is a sales tactic, not a publishing standard.

  10. 10.Their authors can't be found on Amazon, in bookshops, or in libraries.

    Search their recent titles. If you can't find them anywhere, ask where the books are actually being sold.

  11. 11.They claim special relationships with bookshops, media, or prize committees.

    Ask for specifics. Vague claims of connections are a standard vanity press sales technique.

  12. 12.Their website has no named staff, no physical address, or no verifiable history.

    Check Companies House. Check the directors. Check how long the domain has been registered. Anonymity in publishing is a warning sign.

One final note

Every writer who has lost money to a bad publisher asked none of these questions. The publishers who took their money have mostly rebranded. The writers are still out of pocket.

Ask the questions. Get the answers in writing. Have the contract reviewed. The publishing industry has been taking money from writers who didn't know better for a very long time. Now you know better.

Useful resources

  • Society of Authors, societyofauthors.org. Free contract vetting for members. The single most important organisation a traditionally published author can join.
  • Alliance of Independent Authors, allianceindependentauthors.org. Resources, contract advice, and community for self-published authors.
  • Writer Beware, sfwa.org/writer-beware. Tracks vanity presses, scam agents, and predatory publishers. Search any publisher here before signing.
  • Companies House, companieshouse.gov.uk. Free company search. Check the directors, the company age, and whether any related companies have been dissolved.
  • Break The Spell, willmybooksell.com. The writer's intelligence tool. A reality check before you spend thousands.

A free checklist from Belfast Books. Not legal advice. For contract review, contact the Society of Authors or a qualified lawyer. Belfast Books, 112 York Road, Belfast. willmybooksell.com

Get the printable PDF

Prefer to keep the checklist? Enter your email and we'll send you the printable PDF to take to your publisher meetings.

One email with your PDF. We won't spam you.

Want the full toolkit?

Break The Spell is the writer's intelligence tool used by authors who refuse to be sold to. It's open now.

Get Break The Spell →